Which Sig and Why?

[ray1970]

I've been wanting a Sig MK25 for a little while now and was going to pick one up soon. Now, I've kind of been leaning towards the M11-A1 instead. Another part of me was thinking about skipping the Sig altogether and picking up something else for half the price and starting another AR project.

I have my own list of pros and cons between the two Sigs and will probably post them up this evening.

Just thought I would would see what you guys thought about it or which route you would go. Maybe some of you will say something I haven't thought of to help me along in my decision making process.

Thanks.

[drift_g35]

I have the Sig 226 Combat (same as an MK25) and I love it. I do however have a major issue with the slide locking back on empty...BUT, its because of my grip, not the gun. Other than that I have had no malfunctions and its probably the most accurate handgun I own. Another downfall is normal p226 holsters are too small. The rail on the MK25 and Combat are true MIL-STD-1913 rail so its a few millimeters larger the standard rails. I havent had issues with accessories other than a holster though. I'm also wanting a M11-A1 as well. Good luck with whatever you choose.

I'm sure you are probably aware of these issues, but I figured I would point them out just in case.

[SouthPaw]

I was in the same boat as you Ray. I held a sig P226 9mm (I think it was an elite) and I was in love. I was counting my pennies and when I finally had the coin I decided that it wasn't "practical" for me. I didn't really have a "use" for it and I knew it would just sit in the safe. I opted to build another AR15 instead.

I still would like one eventually to add to the collection but for now I'm happy with my decision. Signs makes a very nice firearm. Good luck on your decision and post pictures if you get one!

[Dave]

Only Sig I have shot is a SP2022 I own. For the sub $500 price I love it. Fun at the range and I would trust it to save my life. Picked it over a G19 due to price and how it felt in my hand, glad I did. Only real complaints are the decocker being a bit awkward and Sig mags are expensive as hell.

[ray1970]

I have had (and still have) several Sig handguns, including a P226 Tac-ops, so I am familiar with the platform. I am just hung up in wanting the MK25 since it is the official issue item to the Navy Seals. And, I like the rail on it more than the standard Sig models.

The main reason the M11-A1 intrigues me is because it comes standard with the SRT trigger and has the same capacity as the larger P226 in a slightly smaller package. Also, I think it is the same as the ones the Navy issues their pilots. I think.

[brutal]

Love my Sigs.

Assuming you know the M11 comes with the SRT and short trigger stock, what is your intended use of either?

[whoops, I guess I should refresh the thread before saving my post]

[ray1970]

Assuming you know the M11 comes with the SRT and short trigger stock, what is your intended use of either?


Just a range toy. I like stuff that is pretty authentic military style stuff. Don't want an M9 because I find them a bit awkward and unergonomic.

[brutal]

Just a range toy. I like stuff that is pretty authentic military style stuff. Don't want an M9 because I find them a bit awkward and unergonomic.

If it were me, MK25 and possibly install the SRT and short trigger.

However, my P226's shoot hella good with the regular triggers.

[cstone]

P229 in .357 SIG

It just works.

[ray1970]

P229 in .357 SIG

It just works.

I know you have a soft spot for that caliber but it just isn't my thing. I'm just more mainstream I guess.

[Beer]

[brutal]

P229 in .357 SIG

It just works.

My EDC

But the P226 full size platform in 9mm is sooo nice to shoot.

[drift_g35]

My EDC

But the P226 full size platform in 9mm is sooo nice to shoot.

I will second this. I went to the range earlier this week and was practicing with my 226 with a SRT, then shot by buddies HK P30 (which is also an amazing firearm). But the sig shot so much better with that SRT.

[Dave]

Hopefully this weekend I'll have another Sig to review, if I can get to the range. My father in law gave me a Sig TacOps 5" with accessories and 2 extra mags on our trip to see him in Tucson this weekend. He also gave my wife a Lady Smith revolver to add to her CCW choice.

[funkymonkey1111]

have you considered the new P320 striker fired model?

http://www.sigsauer.com/CatalogProductList/pistols-p320.aspx

[ray1970]

have you considered the new P320 striker fired model?

http://www.sigsauer.com/CatalogProductList/pistols-p320.aspx

Looks like a striker fired P250. Think I'm going to pass on that one.

Thanks for making me aware that it existed. I had no idea.

[Beer]