Glock Advice

[DCusaf]

I have a Springfield Xds 9mm that I bought for concealed carry last year and never really ended up using it for that purpose. I've been bringing it to the range for target shooting and it really isn't accurate enough to have fun practicing with beyond 7 yards. I've been thinking about getting a Glock because Ive never had one and I like the simplicity and customization options that I've heard about with Glocks.

For range use, I'd like something full sized. I'm leaning towards a Glock 17, 17L, or 34. Any recommendations for a primarily range use and self defense weapon for the house? Has anyone bought the 17 and wished for the 34 or 17L instead? How about used versus new? Used Glocks seem to go for about $50 less than new. Do people generally ask too much for them? Gen3 versus Gen4? LGS recommendations in Colorado for new Glocks?


Thanks for for any advice and sorry if this topic has been beaten to death.

[ray1970]

Keep in mind getting standard capacity magazines for the 17/34 is technically against state law. A full size 9mm with ten round magazines just seems a little silly to me. I'd actually recommend a model 19. Small enough for carry yet large enough for range use and the standard fifteen round magazines are still easy and legal to get here. Gen 3 or 4 is really a matter of personal preference. I like the frame texture on the gen 4 but the other features don't really appeal to me personally.

[mtnrider]

I would encourage you to try before you buy if you can. I love everything about Glocks but like many I can't shoot them worth a crap. They are not for everyone.

[hurley842002]

I would encourage you to try before you buy if you can. I love everything about Glocks but like many I can't shoot them worth a crap. They are not for everyone.
Sound advice, I'm the opposite and shoot Glocks better than anything else. I'm also with Ray on the Glock 19.

[SAnd]

I would encourage you to try before you buy if you can. I love everything about Glocks but like many I can't shoot them worth a crap. They are not for everyone.
Totally agree with this one. I have serious difficulty shooting a standard Glock. A lot of shooting ranges have them for rent.

These guys make limiters to restrict mag capacity.
http://www.magazineblocks.com/magento/products/magblock-kits/pistols-3/glock.html
Kinda expensive though.

[HoneyBadger]

Keep in mind getting standard capacity magazines for the 17/34 is technically against state law. A full size 9mm with ten round magazines just seems a little silly to me. I'd actually recommend a model 19. Small enough for carry yet large enough for range use and the standard fifteen round magazines are still easy and legal to get here. Gen 3 or 4 is really a matter of personal preference. I like the frame texture on the gen 4 but the other features don't really appeal to me personally.
I second this.


Sound advice, I'm the opposite and shoot Glocks better than anything else. I'm also with Ray on the Glock 19.
And this. I shoot Glocks better than any other handgun, but lots of people don't. Find what works for you. If you're in Colorado Springs any time soon, give me a holler and we can make a quick trip to the range with my Glock 19.

[wyome]

Sounds like a job for S&W M&P 9!!

Wife loves her G17...I can't shoot straight with it, loved the XD stuff and was ready to buy one until I got to try an M&P 9mm...love at first sight.

If you have to get a Glock the G19 seems like the best compromise between full size, and slight smaller for concealed. Wife has the G19 and shoots the crap outta it....and least 7k rounds down the pipe in a 2011 G17 and prolly 2k shot in the 2012 G19.

[TheBelly]

i used a G19 in uspsa. i didnt feel hindered by it.

[68Charger]

Handguns in general are very personal... Only G-Lock that felt right at all to me was a G20 (not the SF)... But when I tried an M&P with the large back strap, it fit like a glove (not OJ's)...

Try a few to see what fits, and what you shoot well...

[hurley842002]

Handguns in general are very personal... Only G-Lock that felt right at all to me was a G20 (not the SF)

And you went off and sold it to me? Lol

[68Charger]

And you went off and sold it to me? Lol

I know... Hope you're treating her well... I've looked at buying a G20 again... Or maybe the new G40?
If only they made an M&P in 10mm...

[Irving]

If the small size of the XDs was the perceived problem, why are you so certain that going to a full size AND a Glock is the answer? I agree to try and see how some stuff feels.

[Alpha2]

I'm going to go out on a limb here...Don't be afraid to add Walther PPQ to your list of guns to try. I moved from XD's, Glocks, (although it's my go to gun for bedside with a light and backup 3-gun night shoots) and various other pistols. I started with a PPQ 40, then a PPQ 9 for 3-gun. If I had to take any gun to the range, it would be my PPQ. Comfortable, accurate, excellent trigger out of the box, what's not to love!?

I've got a G17, G19, Beretta, Smiths, etc. and a couple of Walthers. If you wan't to shoot some, we can hit a range around Ft. Collins sometime. Expand your horizons!!!

[DCusaf]

I like my XDs fine for what it is. For target shooting, I like the Glock 34 for the much longer sight radius, longer barrel, adjustable sights (wind age and elevation), and the factory 4.5 lb trigger. Just seems like it would be a much better target shooter. The ten round mags versus 15 on the Glock 19 isn't a deal breaker for me.

I don't really need another gun - I just have the itch for something new. Come on, we all have the sickness.

[DCusaf]

I'm going to go out on a limb here...Don't be afraid to add Walther PPQ to your list of guns to try. I moved from XD's, Glocks, (although it's my go to gun for bedside with a light and backup 3-gun night shoots) and various other pistols. I started with a PPQ 40, then a PPQ 9 for 3-gun. If I had to take any gun to the range, it would be my PPQ. Comfortable, accurate, excellent trigger out of the box, what's not to love!?

I've got a G17, G19, Beretta, Smiths, etc. and a couple of Walthers. If you wan't to shoot some, we can hit a range around Ft. Collins sometime. Expand your horizons!!!


Thanks is for offer. I'm in summit county. Hit me up if you want to try our awesome free public shooting range. Pretty dead this time of year too.

[sportbikeco]

http://www.cdnnsports.com/firearms.html?brand=361

Pick one, try them out.

there are some deals out there if you are into .40 or .45 which lets you easily buy full cap mags in state or shipped to home. $350 for a 22 night sights gen 4 in the link.

[ChunkyMonkey]

Or take few basic handgun classes and get the fundamental down then choose your gun. Bob at rw is highly recommended.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[sellersm]

Why not just a full-size XD? Or better yet, a 1911! [handbags]

[Wulf202]

40 cal full size mags feed 9mm in a g17....

[JohnnyEgo]

I am a Glock hater, but I love my G19. Just about the perfect size for any given task. Big enough to use for competition or fun, compact enough for easy carry. I shoot it better than the full sized Glocks I own and dislike, including the 34.

[DCusaf]

Thanks for the advice, everyone. I ended up getting a new 34 Gen 3. It came with 2 17 round mags that were permanently blocked at 15 by the LGS. I took it to the range to sight it in at 25 feet. 1st shot was low and left of center by about 3 inches. Second shot touched the first shot, so did the 3rd. I made a couple of adjustments and proceeded to make a ragged hole in the center of the bullseye. I'll move the target out to 25 yards next time out.

I'm really happy with it so far. The longer sight radius was just what I was looking for. I liked the feel of the Gen 3 trigger and ergonomics better than the Gen 4. Also handled a 17, 19, 22, and 41. The 34 was the sweet spot for me. I'm a Glock fan now.

[Jeffrey Lebowski]

Thanks for the advice, everyone. I ended up getting a new 34 Gen 3. It came with 2 17 round mags that were permanently blocked at 15 by the LGS.

Oh interesting. I guess I wasn't aware anyone was doing this. In fact, for many of the reasons above, I've been shooting a (Gen4) 19 for the same reason but would love a Gen4 17. Been thinking about a 34 myself, but for competition only.

[condoor]

Congrats on your purchase! My 34 is on the list of guns I've sold and wish I hadn't. [Rant2]


Thanks for the advice, everyone. I ended up getting a new 34 Gen 3. It came with 2 17 round mags that were permanently blocked at 15 by the LGS. I took it to the range to sight it in at 25 feet. 1st shot was low and left of center by about 3 inches. Second shot touched the first shot, so did the 3rd. I made a couple of adjustments and proceeded to make a ragged hole in the center of the bullseye. I'll move the target out to 25 yards next time out.

I'm really happy with it so far. The longer sight radius was just what I was looking for. I liked the feel of the Gen 3 trigger and ergonomics better than the Gen 4. Also handled a 17, 19, 22, and 41. The 34 was the sweet spot for me. I'm a Glock fan now.