PDA

View Full Version : 22LR Rimfire Suppressor and Transonic Velocity Range



zimagold
01-29-2015, 20:09
Anyone hear of a suppressed rounds noise increasing as the speed of sound is approached?

I am new to owning suppressors. In my recent trips to the range, I have been surprised to find my bolt action seemed noticeably loader than my semi-auto with CCI Standard Velocity. Same suppressor, same barrel length (16”).
Doing some research, I found notes that sound generated by a projectile increases just before the speed of sound. The more margin to the speed of sound, the less noise. The recommendations I found were of making sure the suppressed round velocity is 7-8% below the current speed of sound given local conditions.

Indoor Range, 70 F = 1128 ft/sec (Speed of Sound)
Less 8%, 1038 ft/sec (Best Noise Reduction vs. Velocity Loss)

I went back to the range with a chronograph.
- 16” Bolt: 1072 ft/sec
- 16” Semi-Auto: 1033 ft/sec (I assume the velocity drop is due to energy being lost in the blow back action)

I guess I previously always thought of the speed of sound as a limit not to cross. This has me rethinking my subsonic loads for 300 Blackout and looking for another (Edit: 22LR) subsonic load. Anyone else experience this before?

Circuits
01-29-2015, 21:33
My biggest surprise shooting suppressed 22 has been first round pop. Empty/cold can volume, the first shot seems almost unsuppressed, then eerily quiet, almost dead silent except for action noise after that first shot.

Standard velocity is well below supersonic in all my 22 delivery systems, so I've never experienced the issue you're experiencing.

zimagold
01-29-2015, 21:44
I have been fortunate, the AAC ELement II seems to have very little FRP.

I was initially really disappointed in the Element on the bolt gun compared to ones I had heard before with friends. Then I tried it on my S&W 15-22 and I couldn't stop smiling. Definitely different.

Maybe I got a hot batch of CCI SV. Will try something else in the bolt and run the CCI SV through the 15-22.

Great-Kazoo
01-29-2015, 22:21
Outside of FRP, shooting standard velocity 22lr the DB reduction is good across the board. Most of my shooting is done using fed bulk pack, or CCI 40gr.

zimagold
01-29-2015, 22:30
Maybe my ears are playing tricks on me

Edit: I don't have a sound meter, so its just my perception.

XC700116
01-29-2015, 23:46
Is it possible that the sound of the action on the semi-auto is "drowning out" some of the perceived report on it vs the bolt gun which is only the firing pin and the report?

Dunno, just throwing it out there, I haven't had mine on anything but my bolt gun yet and all I shoot through it is Eley and CCI std.

zimagold
01-30-2015, 19:17
Is it possible that the sound of the action on the semi-auto is "drowning out" some of the perceived report on it vs the bolt gun which is only the firing pin and the report?

Dunno, just throwing it out there, I haven't had mine on anything but my bolt gun yet and all I shoot through it is Eley and CCI std.

Definitely affected by the action noise. Will be trying again with a few friends to get a general opinion.

zimagold
01-30-2015, 19:18
Has anyone tried this new ammo?

Federal American Eagle Suppressor - 45gr Copper Platted.

http://www.midwayusa.com/product/995680/federal-american-eagle-suppressor-ammunition-22-long-rifle-45-grain-copper-plated-lead-round-nose-box-of-500-10-boxes-of-50

Edit: Seems like a good option with heavier bullet and cost of $28 per 500, if its ever in stock.

Great-Kazoo
01-30-2015, 20:22
I don't have any issues with the fed bulk pack or fed auto match.
Regarding the fired round being louder. I have a YHM Cobra in 45. On the 357 lever it's bolt action quiet. For use on my glock it's one of the worst sounding cans i've ever owned or shot. If one were to inquire for a purchase, i'd strongly advise against it. Not that this has anything to do with your question.

DFBrews
01-30-2015, 21:20
I had some fed bulk pack to close to supersonic come out of the mark ii I heard the bullet moving through the air more so than cci sv. The report was pretty much the same sparrow ss can

zimagold
02-04-2015, 20:32
Got a hold of a new brick of CCI Standard Velocity. Much better on noise. I alternated the batches in the mag and you could actually hear a difference in the "wind" noise of the round traveling down range. No chronograph data, but I'm happy with the performance.

The only fed bulk I have is 36gr super sonic, which makes a nice crack in my rifles.

Alpha2
02-05-2015, 19:47
Has anyone tried this new ammo?

Federal American Eagle Suppressor - 45gr Copper Platted.

http://www.midwayusa.com/product/995680/federal-american-eagle-suppressor-ammunition-22-long-rifle-45-grain-copper-plated-lead-round-nose-box-of-500-10-boxes-of-50

Edit: Seems like a good option with heavier bullet and cost of $28 per 500, if its ever in stock.

I've got some of that stuff. It's quiet. It also cycles all my semi-auto pistols. I also have some CCI Quiet stuff now, actually quite a lot of it. Won't cycle the semi-auto pistols, planning to run some through the 15-22 soon.
I've got a Tactical Innovations Stratus can. (Hint: take it apart, regularly, clean it well, take it apart again, often, clean it...)

zimagold
02-05-2015, 20:12
I've got some of that stuff. It's quiet. It also cycles all my semi-auto pistols. I also have some CCI Quiet stuff now, actually quite a lot of it. Won't cycle the semi-auto pistols, planning to run some through the 15-22 soon.
I've got a Tactical Innovations Stratus can. (Hint: take it apart, regularly, clean it well, take it apart again, often, clean it...)

I've tried a few boxes of the CCI Quiet, name fits. Didn't have any luck with it cycling my 15-22. I would like to try the newer version of CCI quiet that is segmented for rodents.

Alpha2
02-07-2015, 09:32
Thanks for the info. Maybe I'll unload all those 15-22 mags today...

Zima, just checked my stash, all mine is the round nose.