PDA

View Full Version : Suppressor question



rondog
08-29-2015, 09:49
This may be a silly question, but I'm curious -

Can a suppressor made for a .223 AR also be used on a .22lr single-shot bolt rifle? Since the bullet diameters are nearly the same I'd think so, but since the cartridges are vastly different I may be totally wrong.

Would it work OK or not?

Not like I can afford one, but maybe someday. I'd just like to know. Thanks!

ray1970
08-29-2015, 09:53
It would work but eventually the lead and crap from the Rimfire rounds would ruin a very nice suppressor.

Most rimfire cans can be disassembled for cleaning. The centerfire cans... usually not. They typically are sealed units to withstand the pressure generated by a centerfire cartridge.

I'm sure there are some exceptions but I bet they're pricey.

mutt
08-29-2015, 09:57
You could but since .22lr is so filthy you'd probably ruin the.223 can eventually. I think most manufacture warranties would be voided if you did this. 22lr cans are specifically designed to be taken apart easily so you can clean them. I wouldn't do it

rondog
08-29-2015, 10:05
Ah, see there? Something totally different that I never thought of! I knew it couldn't be that simple. But since I've never even touched a can, let alone fired one.....

68Charger
08-29-2015, 10:33
Form 1, make your own- the freeze plug & solvent trap design can be disassembled and cleaned, so will do both just fine.
Sure you'll get better performance from a commercial can, but I think there are more upsides to building your own.

One of these days I'm going to send in a form 1 and get started. 300BLK has me really interested.

rondog
08-29-2015, 10:37
Form 1, make your own- the freeze plug & solvent trap design can be disassembled and cleaned, so will do both just fine.
Sure you'll get better performance from a commercial can, but I think there are more upsides to building your own.

One of these days I'm going to send in a form 1 and get started. 300BLK has me really interested.

Eh, for the cheapo route I'd probably just go with that adapter that uses automotive oil filters. It's my old single-shot Remington 514 that I'd really like to put a can on, not my AR.

XC700116
08-29-2015, 10:42
As long as the can is all SS and/or TI you can do it just fine with no ill effects, just by cleaning it afterwards in "the dip".

Now if you do it on a can that has some Aluminum in it, you can't put it in the dip without destroying it.

My 22 can is 100% TI and is a sealed unit just like my big rifle can. All that needs to be done is to throw it in the dip for a while after a few shooting sessions, rinse it out, let it dry, and get back to work with it.

BTW, there's a few pretty highly respected guys on this board that run a LOT of 22 lr through high dollar 30 cal rifle cans and have no ill effects from doing so.

Great-Kazoo
08-29-2015, 12:30
I run 22 in a 223 can. Unless you're going crazy (2 550 bulk packs) per range trip. A 1/2 doz rounds of 223 "should" blow that crap out. For $200 stamp and some spare time you can do a 22 can. I have some parts sitting here you can have (barter) for.
You can build (after approval) a 22 can for under $150, Tops if that. I have a scrap yard down the road, probably run me $20 for everything, maybe $50 if i found something choice.

Hell i might do it just for sheets n geegles.

brutal
08-29-2015, 12:45
Form 1, make your own- the freeze plug & solvent trap design can be disassembled and cleaned, so will do both just fine.
Sure you'll get better performance from a commercial can, but I think there are more upsides to building your own.

One of these days I'm going to send in a form 1 and get started. 300BLK has me really interested.

Yea, kick myself weekly for the one I've had sitting in draft for months. Have the parts except for freeze plugs of course. I *might* know a guy or two that have the tools. I could have had the stamp and built by now. [Bang]

Great-Kazoo
08-29-2015, 14:18
Yea, kick myself weekly for the one I've had sitting in draft for months. Have the parts except for freeze plugs of course. I *might* know a guy or two that have the tools. I could have had the stamp and built by now. [Bang]

Likewise. Think after re-reading this thread, i'm filing another F1 can. This one a 22. Tax Stamps, the gifts you keep on giving yourself . Who knows this one might be approved in time for my 60th b-day [panic]

dwd1985
08-30-2015, 04:50
..

fitz19d
09-15-2015, 13:12
So related question, I know I've seen/heard it being done before, but what are thoughts on a .308 supp also used on 5.56/.223? Assuming could get matching threads or quick detach mount sizes. (Not sure how many off the shelf options there are to do that.)

Personally I like things that go bang/boom and concussion is awesome. So generally I've never been interested in suppressors much even though it's still a cornerstone should be tried option. With my upcoming bolt gun purchase, I think its the first firearm where I think I like the idea of a suppressor. But still costly, + stamp money, + time. It would help sway me more if down the road with the MDR I could also slap it on the .308 and .223 barrels both.

izzy
09-15-2015, 13:22
I use a 308 can on a 5.56 rifle all the time. It works great.

fitz19d
09-15-2015, 13:36
Did you have to get a custom threaded barrel, or anything like that? I thought the standard threading for each size was different or at least the outside circumfrerence likely different? Or possibly a brake for each that ends in a quick attach that shares same size?

izzy
09-15-2015, 13:40
I have an AAC can, had to put their break on all my rifles. It works very well on all the rifles I've put it on. I've had it on a SCAR 17, .308 bolt and two different 5.56 ARs.

fitz19d
09-15-2015, 13:47
Cool, well that solves that at least, though I'm still such an addict to brake/comps might still prefer if I could direct thread on so I can still readily swap out with my preferred brake.

izzy
09-15-2015, 16:05
AAC has a few different styles on their breaks. I'm not really that into breaks in general so I can't speak to how well they stack up to others.

Blowby
09-15-2015, 16:13
Using TBAC CB9 on the .308 and .223 without any problems other than dirty AR bcg.

Picture from web to show the mounting.
60964

TRnCO
09-16-2015, 15:56
Personally I like things that go bang/boom and concussion is awesome. So generally I've never been interested in suppressors much You must be young and without any noticeable hearing lose yet? A suppressor will help save your hearing and if you can save yourself from having tinnitus, the price is well worth it. Unless, of course, you would totally enjoy 24/7/365 high pitched ringing in your ears.

fitz19d
09-16-2015, 16:16
Already have a little going, more noticable is my sense of smell is pretty reduced. I'ma young gimp.

As much as I like loud, I do double up on in ear + over ear. Been indoors point blank to an AR with no ear pro, decent list of different things outdoors. So guess I should say I don't love it so much that I just run around with kleenex ear pro.

rondog
09-16-2015, 16:19
You must be young and without any noticeable hearing lose yet? A suppressor will help save your hearing and if you can save yourself from having tinnitus, the price is well worth it. Unless, of course, you would totally enjoy 24/7/365 high pitched ringing in your ears.

Me, I already have tinnitus, have had it for many years. Got it bad. Too much loud music and shooting without ear pro. It sux ballz.

Huh? Say what?