PDA

View Full Version : Study investigating using green light to mitigate migraines



Irving
12-15-2019, 23:07
Here is an article about a study that used green light to mitigate migraines. There are a bunch of studies and the article seems balanced and worth the read.

https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2019/12/15/787138928/researchers-explore-a-drug-free-idea-to-relieve-chronic-pain-green-light

def90
12-15-2019, 23:17
A double blind placebo study would ferret it out as being valid or not rather quickly though they do mention the difficulty of doing a placebo study. If this really is a placebo effect of some sort the patients symptoms should eventually come back again once the initial psychological effect fades whether its a month or two or a year or two later.

Irving
12-15-2019, 23:48
Do you mean symptoms coming back while still "treating" with the placebo? Couldn't the same argument be made about symptoms coming back after stopping treatment, for something chronic?

def90
12-15-2019, 23:54
If over time the therapy has a lessening effect/impact and the symptoms gradually return while still performing the therapy it is likely a placebo effect going on. Simply stopping the therapy and having the symptoms return wouldn’t really prove anything. If the therapy worked you would get that result, if it was a placebo you would get the same result.

Irving
12-16-2019, 00:16
We're on the same page.

Gman
12-16-2019, 09:52
The ability to do a blind study vs. placebo reminds me of DMSO used for treating pain. It makes your breath smell like garlic, so there's no way to test it vs. placebo. You know whether or not you've got the real thing.

Gman
12-16-2019, 10:16
I like no lights and cool temps when I have a migraine.

BushMasterBoy
12-16-2019, 10:17
Then what do blue lights do? I prefer the red light district...

Gman
12-16-2019, 10:22
I was wondering about the effect of black lights...

Probably leads to tie-dye.

ray1970
12-16-2019, 10:24
They should see if bright white strobe lights help headaches.

FoxtArt
12-16-2019, 19:54
Then what do blue lights do? I prefer the red light district...True fact: they apparently damage your vision, albet very, very slowly.

TFOGGER
12-16-2019, 20:10
Not long after I started getting classical migraines in my teens, I discovered that I could mitigate or at least postpone the worst of the symptoms with caffeine. My doctor at the time told me this was purely placebo effect and that caffeine could not possibly be helpful. Fast forward 20 years, and Johns Hopkins published a massive study that indicated that caffeine was beneficial in over 90 percent of the patients in their double blind study, as opposed to 22 percent of the the patients receiving the placebo. Medical sc ience is not nearly as advanced as many physicians would like you to believe...

Irving
12-16-2019, 21:32
My parents have a stove with a clock that is blue led. It hurts just to look at it and it is blurry at distances that it shouldn't be.

Gman
12-16-2019, 21:55
Not long after I started getting classical migraines in my teens, I discovered that I could mitigate or at least postpone the worst of the symptoms with caffeine. My doctor at the time told me this was purely placebo effect and that caffeine could not possibly be helpful. Fast forward 20 years, and Johns Hopkins published a massive study that indicated that caffeine was beneficial in over 90 percent of the patients in their double blind study, as opposed to 22 percent of the the patients receiving the placebo. Medical sc ience is not nearly as advanced as many physicians would like you to believe...
My 'go to' in my teens was to take a couple of aspirin with a Coke. Excedrin (aspirin, tylenol, caffeine) worked better than many of the prescriptions I was given.

TFOGGER
12-16-2019, 22:07
My parents have a stove with a clock that is blue led. It hurts just to look at it and it is blurry at distances that it shouldn't be.

That's because the wavelength of blue light actually refracts differently in the lens of your eye, causing it to focus just in front of, rather than on, the retina.

Irving
12-17-2019, 01:05
Sounds like blue is a dumb color.

Justin
12-17-2019, 13:35
Sounds like blue is a dumb color.

At least it isn't yellow.

BushMasterBoy
12-17-2019, 13:58
The cause of migraines is idiopathic. I have a theory that it is simply a sensitivity to a parasite. This parasite vector is the species felidae.
I have had the best results with a toxic dose of folinic acid.
12% of the US population suffers from migraines.
When I find the causative agent, I will announce it here first.

Irving
12-17-2019, 14:03
At least it isn't yellow.

I'll meet you half way at Green.