I don't think an online forum can tell you which boot is best for your foot. Each person's foot is so different the Lowas may work great for me but maybe you have no arch in your foot and you hate them. REI is really the way to go. Hell, you have a YEAR to decide you don't like a boot before you can't return it any more.
That being said, I'm on my second set of Lowas - the first one has gone up 25 or so 14ers before it wore out and now I just use it on my motorcycle when I go to and from work.

