http://youtu.be/izYQ6ztcflQ
Printable View
YESQuote:
Originally Posted by brutal
CHP: Drunk driver slept while Tesla appeared to drive Hwy 101 on autopilot
Quote:
When a pair of California Highway Patrol officers pulled alongside a car cruising down Highway 101 in Redwood City before dawn Friday, they reported a shocking sight: a man fast asleep behind the wheel.
The car was a Tesla, the man was a Los Altos planning commissioner, and the ensuing freeway stop turned into a complex, seven-minute operation in which the officers had to outsmart the vehicle’s autopilot system because the driver was unresponsive, according to the CHP.
The arrest of 45-year-old Alexander Samek on suspicion of drunken driving reignited questions about the uses, and potential abuses, of self-driving technology.
Reached by phone Friday afternoon, Samek, a real estate developer who runs the Kor Group, said, “I can’t talk right now,” before hanging up.
Officers observed Samek’s gray Tesla Model S around 3:30 a.m. as it sped south at 70 mph on Highway 101 near Whipple Avenue, said Art Montiel, a CHP spokesman. When officers pulled up next to the car, they allegedly saw Samek asleep, but the car was moving straight, leading them to believe it was in autopilot mode.
The officers slowed the car down after running a traffic break, with an officer behind Samek turning on emergency lights before driving across all lanes of the highway, in an S-shaped path, to slow traffic down behind the Tesla, Montiel said.
He said another officer drove a patrol car directly in front of Samek before gradually slowing down, prompting the Tesla to slow down as well and eventually come to a stop in the middle of the highway, north of the Embarcadero exit in Palo Alto — about 7 miles from where the stop was initiated.
Authorities said the entire operation took about seven minutes.
Officers then walked up to the Tesla and “attempted to wake up Samek by knocking on the window and giving verbal commands,” Montiel said. “After Samek woke up and got out of the Tesla, he was placed in the back of the patrol car and taken off the freeway.”
At a nearby gas station, Montiel said, Samek was given a field sobriety test before being arrested.
Tesla, whose autopilot technology assists in steering, changing lanes and parking, has seen its vehicles involved in several notable accidents in the last few years.
In 2016, a man was killed in Florida after the Model S he was driving collided with a tractor trailer while the Tesla was in autopilot mode. In January, a man was arrested on suspicion of driving under the influence on the Bay Bridge. He told officers he had been using his Tesla’s autopilot mode. Also this year, a man driving a Model X on Highway 101 in Mountain View was killed after his vehicle, which was in autopilot mode, struck a concrete divider.
The company declined to comment on Friday’s incident.
On its website, Tesla notes that its autopilot technology is not synonymous with self-driving cars or autonomous vehicles, and that drivers must keep their hands on the wheel at all times.
William Riggs, a professor of transportation, technology and engineering at the University of San Francisco, said most cars have some variation of autonomous features, and as the technology advances, people will feel more comfortable being distracted when driving.
“The software and technology is so good that humans are going to violate it,” Riggs said. “The future of autonomy really invites a lot of opportunities to disengage from the driving activity as we see more and more AI in control of vehicles.”
John Simpson, privacy and technology project director with Consumer Watchdog, saw Friday’s incident as further evidence of Tesla drivers being inappropriately led to believe the autopilot function is akin to fully autonomous driving.
In May, Simpson’s organization and the Center for Auto Safety asked the Federal Trade Commission to investigate “deceptive and unfair” practices in the advertising and marketing of the autopilot feature.
“They’ve really unconscionably led people to believe, I think, that the car is far more capable of self-driving than actually is the case. That’s a huge problem,” Simpson said. “In this case, it sounds as if it played out with some incredible work by the state police — the Highway Patrol — to get the car to stop. But it’s really amazing they were able to do that.”
Jim McPherson, a Bay Area attorney and industry analyst, said the autopilot feature is supposed to cut out if the driver doesn’t keep a hand on the wheel and exert “a minimal amount of torque.”
“But the length of the warning is variable. It could be a few seconds, it could be a minute or two,” McPherson said. “It’s really quite a miracle that this guy continued for 7 miles without autopilot cutting out.”
McPherson said he would expect the autopilot system to have alerted the driver to keep his hands on the wheel.
“Also, if he’s asleep, any more than a slight nudge of the wheel or touch of the pedal is going to cancel autopilot,” McPherson said. “So for it to get as far as it did, it’s a surprise to me.”
Riggs said the best time to use autopilot technology is during long highway trips, but those situations also pose hazards because drivers are usually less engaged than they would be in more urban settings.
“You’re more likely to have a distracted driver,” he said. “That can create a false sense of security.”
As the technology advances, many experts argue that having more autonomous vehicles on the road will lead to safer driving and fewer collisions. However, the technological progression must be accompanied by policies that clearly dictate when drivers should take the wheel, Riggs said.
“We haven’t really grappled yet with policing what happens in the vehicle,” he said. “If we throw people in vehicles and assume they don’t have to be operators, that should be transparent to them.”
I knew someone that had one (those partial windows were a trip). The ECU went out and the replacement part was insanely expensive at the time.Quote:
Originally Posted by Irving
That's pretty interesting. If it was in auto-pilot, I wonder what it did that attracted police attention in the first place. Seems like the auto pilot would be a blessing for drunk drivers hoping to make it home under the radar.
Just more FUD from the MSM.Quote:
Originally Posted by Gman
That's not how Autopilot works on Tesla vehicles so I don't see how this is even possible how it's presented. Cars are prohibited at the Federal level from being fully autonomous which forces manufacturers like Tesla to put safeguards in that require input from the driver assuring the car is "assisting" the driver. One such example is that the car has to sense minimal resistance on the steering wheel every 30 seconds or so or it will warn you with flashing lights & a reminder, then an audible cue while lowering stereo volume and finally complete disengagement and inability to activate for the remainder of that drive. It's not possible to be "fast asleep" as reported here for more than thirty seconds or so with Autopilot engaged.
I also love how they say that Autopilot has had "numerous accidents in the last few years" trying to plant little seeds of doubt at every turn with no comparison data to cars w/o Autopilot.
So if it's not 100% accident free it's a complete failure? Never mind that vehicles on autopilot have proven to be far safer than vehicles not on autopilot. One accident happens and the MSM makes it sound like these things are driving everyone into walls or intentionally killing them. Much like firearms they don't report the stories of all of the lives saved and countless accidents avoided as a direct result of cars being on Autopilot. There's several videos online that are montages of cars avoiding accidents due to Autopilot. None of that gets talked about though because we all know that negativity and sensationalism is what drives clicks just like this horse shit "article"" posted here.
Back to this "news report" link. If this story is legit as reported (which it isn't) would we all be safer if the guy didn't have Autopilot? This idea that Autopilot somehow caused him to drive is BS because even if he had a Ford Taurus he would have still drove home. That's what stupid drunks do. Even if the story was accurate as reported it just means that whatever drivers or pedestrians were near this car that night were all safer as a direct result of Autopilot.
Some on this forum are so sharp to how the MSM pushes agendas when it comes to firearms & negativity but then are blind to these exact same tactics in other segments.
So what you're saying Jer is that it's impossible for this guy to pass out with one hand on the wheel?
Where's the diesel pickups @ in this thread
In the title!Quote:
Originally Posted by wyome
[facepalm]
Winner! [LOL]Quote:
Originally Posted by BladesNBarrels