Originally Posted by
Milt
"Of course, everyone always has the option of committing a crime but when they ask a question, they are asking for help in not committing a crime"
Correction: 'crime' is NOT the correct term to use in this context. The statute being discussed is itself illegal; on the state level, it clearly, "calls into question" the "right of the people to keep and bear arms in defense of themselves and of the state" and it "infringes" on a U.S. Constitutionally protected right - it is therefore not a 'law', but a statute enforced 'under color of law'.
From a purely conceptual perspective, if there is no victim (someone harmed against their will) there is no crime; it might be 'against the law', but it is not a crime.