http://supreme.justia.com/us/268/5/case.html
Thoughts?
Printable View
The link needs a translation into English.
Really?!? it's in English for me....
You might be able to understand legalese English... [Shock]
My brain hurts now....
oh, haha... bottom line: due to a descision made by the Supreme Court years ago, the Obamacare thing is unconstitutional and cannot legally be mandatory.
Quote:
Originally Posted by BigBear
Took 'em that long to say that?
Never happened though...[Wink] It will convenetly be "lost"...
Thank you. I have trouble understanding lawyer-speak.
The old ruling will help but judges that ignor the constition will feel no obligation to follow any prior rulings. They courts can also rule that one part is unconstitional and leave the rest standing. If they rule that the mandatory purchase part is a no-go they can leave the rest alone. That will just accelerate the end of nongovernment health care, not stop it.
I wish ALL regulations and laws had to be written in plain language and includ the whole law. Any amendments should include the orginal and changed language.
didn't they include a clause that says once the health bill was passed it can never be repealed, ever?
democracy in action, folks.
Frankly that's what I expect to happen, and I think that's by design.Quote:
Originally Posted by SAnd
The purpose of this health care law is to implode the health insurance industry forcing the government to step in and nationalize the industry and bam, overnight and without voting for it we'll get socialized medicine. Once the people are dependent on the state for their very lives you'll never see small government, pro-liberty constitutionalists in power again. Ever. Period.
Folks I think we have to face the fact that Obama has already "fundamentally transformed this country" beyond the point of no return and the only way to roll this crap back is with some sort of "reset button" (be that a Constitutional Convention or a dissolution of the union ... a con-con will end up making things worse since the progressives will write all sorts of new positive rights and eliminate many rights related to liberty, and secession and/or dissolution isn't going to go any smoother or peacefully than it did last time it was tried).
America is dead ... the corpse just hasn't started stinking yet.
Sometimes, I'm afraid you're right....Quote:
Originally Posted by Zundfolge
doesn't matter what the supreme court says. doesn't matter what the constitution says. this our dear leader, anything is possible!
They can say what they like, but one congress cannot bind a later congress. Only the constitution can do that.Quote:
Originally Posted by Elhuero
At best it can be taken to mean that THIS 111th Congress cannot repeal it, but the next congress (which starts in January 2011) and any later one can.
I don't know, I think certain parts (San Francisco, Hollyweird, DC, NYC, etc.) started stinking a long time ago ...Quote:
Originally Posted by Zundfolge
AGREED.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zundfolge
+1Quote:
Originally Posted by Aloha_Shooter
Damn ... I was hoping I'd see a bunch of responses disagreeing with my pessimistic take on things ... telling me to stop being so negative and pointing out how wrong I am.
:(
Yeah......sucks, don't it?Quote:
Originally Posted by Zundfolge