Personally, as I used to be a pretty big cigar guy, I think you can do better than Cubans- yeah they're good, but most of their appeal to Americans is the fact that they're illegal... the rebellious aspect. I like Dominicans, mostly because the flavor and robust nature (and go great with a glass of brandy or bourbon). I'd have to say my favorites are Arturo Fuente, CAO, and Montecristo but I'll delve into Cohibas and Onyx makes some really good cigars. One of my favorites downrange that I ordered were the CAO Soprano Edition ones, they were very good. But alas, I haven't smoked a cigar in probably 2 years. centrarchidae is spot on with Edwards- they're great there and usually will give some really good recommendations as to what you should try.