Lone Survivor Trailer finally!

[RYAN50BMG]

I just watched the trailer. As an action flick, it looks good. BUT, I have read the book and I will stand by this..... Good men died because of their own "I,m a bullet proof Navy Seal hooah" bullshit! Four guys are NOT direct action anything. You get comprimised, you extract. I am not a fan of Marcus or his book. If you want to read about real hero's, check out "Thirty Seconds over Tokyo". As the "Lone Survivor", Marcus should have been court martialed. Again, I stand by this post, so let's get it on.

[bogie]

I just watched the trailer. As an action flick, it looks good. BUT, I have read the book and I will stand by this..... Good men died because of their own "I,m a bullet proof Navy Seal hooah" bullshit! Four guys are NOT direct action anything. You get comprimised, you extract. I am not a fan of Marcus or his book. If you want to read about real hero's, check out "Thirty Seconds over Tokyo". As the "Lone Survivor", Marcus should have been court martialed. Again, I stand by this post, so let's get it on.

I was under the impression that their extraction was destroyed in the air, along with a lot of good men??

[Squeeze]

I was under the impression that their extraction was destroyed in the air, along with a lot of good men??

It was. Regardless of how Ryan50BMG feels about Marcus & his book....many good men died that day. I, along with everyone else here, was not there. Therefore it is not appropriate for me to question the actions of those who were. They made a judgement call and shit fell apart. That being said, I would highly doubt the judgement call made that day on that mountain side had ANYTHING to do with the macho SEAL bravado. My .02

[RYAN50BMG]

I was under the impression that their extraction was destroyed in the air, along with a lot of good men??

It may have been, long after the shit hit the fan. Read the book, if you have not already, you will understand my point of view.

[Aloha_Shooter]

I just watched the trailer. As an action flick, it looks good. BUT, I have read the book and I will stand by this..... Good men died because of their own "I,m a bullet proof Navy Seal hooah" bullshit! Four guys are NOT direct action anything. You get comprimised, you extract. I am not a fan of Marcus or his book. If you want to read about real hero's, check out "Thirty Seconds over Tokyo". As the "Lone Survivor", Marcus should have been court martialed. Again, I stand by this post, so let's get it on.

I read the book too and that's a load of hooey. They were attempting to extract. I can't even begin to guess what kind of medications you need to be on to say he should have been court-martialed -- on what charges? The fact he DIDN'T violate the Law of Armed Conflict? I haven't met a lot of SEALs but the ones I have never had the "bullet proof" attitude you're claiming. In fact, I remember one of them vetoing a proposed mission because it was too risky. Good men did indeed die that day but it wasn't any fault of Murph's team.

[stoner01]

^^Agreed.

[Superorb]

Every time I see a gun show up in a movie/TV Show they always make a slide/safety/metallic sound that just bugs the hell out of me. I mean, come on people. Guns don't just make sounds all by themselves. I hope this movie is different.

[RYAN50BMG]

I'm all about a a spirited talk about "Lone Survivor", Marcus, his book, and any upcoming movie, but folks saw fit to launch personal attacks... [MOD EDIT] I admit "court martial" may have been over the top...but the ONLY reason Marcus is around to tell his story is because brave Afgan villagers refused to turn him over to the Talliban. If the the Talliban are willing to shoot a little girl on her way to school, I have no dought these simple folks payed a high price for their courage.

[Squeeze]

I never once "attacked you" Ryan but you want to blanket all of us with your name calling, belittling and last I checked, I never slept with my mother. Glad to see guys like you have a hold on your temper so well....and are armed.

Perhaps a locked thread and a "time-out" for Ryan is appropriate...but it's not my call. Regardless...hugely inappropriate.

[Chad4000]

well anyway.... movie looks cool lol