Close
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 15 of 15
  1. #11
    QUITTER Irving's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    Denver, CO
    Posts
    46,527
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    I can certainly see the flawed logic in believing that open carry will deter all crime. I should have made it clear that I didn't bother to read this (or any of the other "articles") posted by the OP, because I've read them all before. I should have tailored my response to better explain that my only point in posting in any of these open carry threads, is to point out that saying that "open carry makes you a target," is stupid.

    If some dudes want to rob a couple walking down the street, but there is a bar half a block down with a big bouncer standing outside, those dudes aren't going to go after the buff bouncer first, then rob the couple. They are just going to rob the couple and run.

    The grocery store example is still weak, because you are talking about unarmed people, who would be required to close the gap and come into physical contact with the guy. An armed citizen is not as likely to be in that situation.

    I guess my main hang up is that people use some movie example of a team of 10 ex-military guys doing an organized hit on a bank while you are open carrying in the lobby. Those guys may think to neutralize you, but you wouldn't stand much more of a chance if you were carrying concealed either; unless you didn't draw the gun at all. Even though NOT drawing would be likely, and the smart thing to do, it's the same as not having a gun at all.

    I conceal carry instead of open carry, but you'll never catch me telling someone that they shouldn't open carry, because there is no reason to tell anyone that.
    "There are no finger prints under water."

  2. #12

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by foxtrot View Post
    Thats the worst argument possible.
    By that logic, everyone assumes all unarmed citizens are armed. Police and military are assumed to be armed. There is no concealment or blending in when there is no choice in the matter.

    And most off duty cops do carry concealed... last I checked.

    Oh, and your absolutely correct, petty theft happens more often. That's akin to saying, fender benders happen more often then fatal car accidents, so don't worry about wearing your seat belt as it PROBABLY won't happen.

    And, your right, someone would PROBABLY overlook an open carry, if they were PROBABLY in a hurry. For that matter, if they are PROBABLY going to overlook it, exactly how the hell does it deter crime in the first place? You can't have your cake and eat it too.

    Personally, I don't like to risk my personal safety on "PROBABLY". but, thats a difference of opinion.

    Another factor you will see with a lot of concealed carry folk is they don't like other people - gun owners included - to know they carry, or where they carry, or often, what they carry. They want the information on how they will defend themselves, or if they will defend themselves, to be cutoff from the world, in the unlikely (but possible) event, someone is ever bent on coming after them. If you always open carry a 45 on your left side in a black holster on your belt, everyone in your life is going to know it. Typically, strangers don't kill strangers, and if someone is pissed off enough to come after you (not to steal your watch) they are going to have the advance intel to know exactly what your reaction would be. Will that prevent them from acting? maybe. Will that limit your options if it doesn't? You really won't have any.

    The problem with open carry, is not that it will deter some crime.. sure it will. It's what happens if it doesn't? You can't be naive enough to think having a gun on your belt will deter 100% of people out there. In the event someone notices it before hand, and it does not deter them (cause and effect) your a goner. Unless your Psychic and know what everybody is going to do, concealed or open carry is always REACTIVE. You can't act until a thread has become apparent, and in this event, that threat will not have become apparent until it (possibly) kills you.

    Also, the difference between me and the guy who wrote the original article? I don't place bets on what will or won't happen. Fact of the matter is, whatever happens will always catch you off guard, and you can't predict it. There are millions of potential situations that can happen. Only a small fraction fit in with the OP's article-writer's intention. Almost none will you have any mental preparation or advanced warning.

    That grocery store example? That happened. this city, about ten years ago. Two unarmed men tried to stop him, he shot both before they even had a chance. Then his girlfriend. Then himself. Weak example? It's called LIFE. Would he have noticed an open carry? I won't guess either way, the possibility exists. He didn't come in guns blazing. He caught the entire store off guard. I do know he would not have been deterred by one (and that a concealed carry, or an unnoticed open carry, would both have had the chance to stop him, and save 3 lives that day)

    The original article has been written with the mindset that EVERYTHING can be deterred with open carry. That by carrying openly, a person will NEVER have to use it. Can you not see the flawed logic?

    When it all comes down to it, it's a matter of personal opinion. I'm not saying you should not open carry. That's your right and your choice. I'm saying the O.Post has a very limited perspective on the situation and doesn't represent the full picture, and both sides of the issue.

    Much better post than your rant. I can see some of the things you are saying. I just feel the public needs to be educated that it is legal for me to carry a gun. That is why I am going to open carry for a while. I prefer not to draw attention to myself and that is the reason I will probably go back to concealed carry after I feel I have done my part to educate the public. Unless during my experiment with open carry I decide it is better than concealed. Right now OC is kind of a trip!

  3. #13

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    the Springs
    Posts
    2,581

    Default

    open carry?

    the fact that it scares the sheeple and pisses off the liberals is more than enough reason for me.

  4. #14
    Guest
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Colorado Springs
    Posts
    165

    Default

    We really need the mods to merge these two current OC threads.

    There are some good arguments for and against. I appreciate Foxtrots take on some reasons to not open carry, he makes some good points to consider.

    Personally, I prefer to conceal carry. Perhaps I do like to maintain the element of surprise and maybe it's because I am lazy and don't want to deal with the potential hassle. Ultimately, I believe that if I choose to open carry, it is my decision and I am willing to assume all the responsibilities that go along with that choice.

    As the temperature increases this Summer, I am more likely to OC simply because it is more convenient than to figure out a wardrobe to cover my pistol. It's not a fashion statement to wear an exposed pistol, and it's not there to piss off the sheeple. I will carry, open or concealed, for the same reasons, because bad things happen at inopportune times and I want to be ready. I also will carry because I can.

  5. #15
    Varmiteer ryanek9freak's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    Colorado Springs
    Posts
    508

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Elhuero View Post
    open carry?

    the fact that it scares the sheeple and pisses off the liberals is more than enough reason for me.
    Part of the reason I OC. I use it as an opportunnity to educate them abou Colorado laws. I informed a lady that it was legal to do so, and she said "That's complete bullshit, and if it's true, then I'm going to do something about it" I heard from a friend of mine, that overheard her conversation with a police officer, that he pretty much laughed at her, and said I was well within the law. She got all red faced pissed off and vowed to get revenge on me or something.

    People like her are more dangerous than anyone with a gun.
    I spent my Obama Stimulus money on a GUN!

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •