Caliber debates about pistols are worthless

[<MADDOG>]

I don't think anyone wants to stand against anyone in a fire fight.

By this story: some of the evil mutherfuckers in this world will just do that...

This isn't about standing against anyone. It's about someone making a statement. Hence Put up or Shut up.

I'm not questioning his pedigree. Having a structured shooting comp is way different than fighting for your life.

Great One, I somewhat disagree with you. The original OP was about a po-po standing against a bad guy.. So, IMO, it is not only about one standing against another, but also the tools.

In the same breath; I agree with Cha Lee and disagree at the same time (oxymoron I know).

(Disclosure: all of these are my opinions!)

Do I think Cha Lee can hit a target under stress-yes.

Is it the same stress as a fire fight? Maybe; the human mind is a crazy f'ng thing...

Is he better prepared/trained than most of the jacklegs critiquing his statements? IMO-yes. I know g-damn well if I were to face the normal "gang banger" or skinny/hadji vs a Cha Lee: I'd take the former over Cha any day of the week...

But that does mean he has the right to critique those who have been in a fire-fight without being in one himself- Hell no. It comes down to mentality, experience, and training IMO.

My opinion.