Close
Results 1 to 10 of 46

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Machine Gunner Brian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Parker/Aurora
    Posts
    1,611

    Default

    Sorry, I didn't word that very well, but that was my point. I've heard very mixed reviews on what you can and cannot use in one of these. Hornady clearly advertises it's made for cleaning upper receiver groups and small parts, but then the vast "wisdom" of the internet seems to claim you can't dump your lower in it, or it will dissolve into fairy dust or something. I shoot a lot suppressed, and the idea that I could disassemble the gun and drop it in a tank, dirty mags and all, is really appealing. But not if it's going to somehow mess with the anodizing or something.

    Would really like to hear from someone who has dunked their AR a few dozen times.

  2. #2
    Machine Gunner Circuits's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Colofornia Springs, CO
    Posts
    2,411

    Default

    The maker of my tank (Sharper Tek) warns that "mirror finishes on aluminum can be dulled" from cleaning in an ultrasonic tank, and recommend use of a "dispersion plate" they sell if you're going to be cleaning mirror-finished aluminum pieces. I don't believe the same applies to the hard-coat anodized surfaces of an AR upper and lower, but who knows?

    I use simple green aircraft as my detergent, and haven't noticed any negative effects on the uppers or lowers I've cleaned in my tanks, but I haven't gone through a dozen cycles on any of the parts yet, as I only dunk the rifles if they're extra filthy (usually after MG rentals), otherwise I still just clean by hand. I've also done big batches of magazines in my tanks, using one for a simple green cleaning pass, then a quick dunk in light oil to displace the water and lubricate them before letting them drip drain and air dry.

    I have several smaller tanks I use for BCG assemblies and other small parts - but those are steel, anyway. For large enough tanks, handguns can just be dropped in the basket with the slide locked open, or cylinder swung out. Single actions I disassemble and drop the frame and cylinder as two pieces.

    Quote Originally Posted by Brian View Post
    Sorry, I didn't word that very well, but that was my point. I've heard very mixed reviews on what you can and cannot use in one of these. Hornady clearly advertises it's made for cleaning upper receiver groups and small parts, but then the vast "wisdom" of the internet seems to claim you can't dump your lower in it, or it will dissolve into fairy dust or something. I shoot a lot suppressed, and the idea that I could disassemble the gun and drop it in a tank, dirty mags and all, is really appealing. But not if it's going to somehow mess with the anodizing or something.

    Would really like to hear from someone who has dunked their AR a few dozen times.
    "The only real difference between the men and the boys, is the number and size, and cost of their toys."
    NRA Life, GOA Life, SAF Life, CSSA Life, NRA Certified Instructor Circuits' Feedback

  3. #3
    Machine Gunner Brian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Parker/Aurora
    Posts
    1,611

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Circuits View Post
    The maker of my tank (Sharper Tek) warns that "mirror finishes on aluminum can be dulled" from cleaning in an ultrasonic tank, and recommend use of a "dispersion plate" they sell if you're going to be cleaning mirror-finished aluminum pieces. I don't believe the same applies to the hard-coat anodized surfaces of an AR upper and lower, but who knows?

    I use simple green aircraft as my detergent, and haven't noticed any negative effects on the uppers or lowers I've cleaned in my tanks, but I haven't gone through a dozen cycles on any of the parts yet, as I only dunk the rifles if they're extra filthy (usually after MG rentals), otherwise I still just clean by hand. I've also done big batches of magazines in my tanks, using one for a simple green cleaning pass, then a quick dunk in light oil to displace the water and lubricate them before letting them drip drain and air dry.

    I have several smaller tanks I use for BCG assemblies and other small parts - but those are steel, anyway. For large enough tanks, handguns can just be dropped in the basket with the slide locked open, or cylinder swung out. Single actions I disassemble and drop the frame and cylinder as two pieces.
    Thx, this is exactly the feedback I was looking for. Now I just need to go buy a couple bags of sand. LOL.

  4. #4
    Hatchet Sushi Master Rooskibar03's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    Vail, AZ
    Posts
    2,770

    Default

    Yes I own it and it works great. I should note I've only used the Hornady brand cleaner in mine. Others report simple green works great also.

    It will fit both of my uppers 14.5" and 16" with no issue. I'm sure a 18" would fit.

    You cannot get the entire lower into the tank without removing the grip and stock. With those removed it would fit just find but I simply turn it upside down and suspend the lower with the bands provided.

    Ive put both a Noveske and a Spikes in there and not had any issues. I've put almost every gun I own short of AK and shotties since they don't fit.

    It seems like it's hard on finishes, especially the Nitron on my Sigs, but after they are done cleaning I rinse with water, blow them dry and then wipe them down with oil and they shine right back up.

    For a really dirty gun there is nothing better. For quick cleaning it's overkill. It takes a bit of time to make sure you've got all the water out of the nooks and crannies.






    Quote Originally Posted by Brian View Post
    Sorry, I didn't word that very well, but that was my point. I've heard very mixed reviews on what you can and cannot use in one of these. Hornady clearly advertises it's made for cleaning upper receiver groups and small parts, but then the vast "wisdom" of the internet seems to claim you can't dump your lower in it, or it will dissolve into fairy dust or something. I shoot a lot suppressed, and the idea that I could disassemble the gun and drop it in a tank, dirty mags and all, is really appealing. But not if it's going to somehow mess with the anodizing or something.

    Would really like to hear from someone who has dunked their AR a few dozen times.
    Last edited by Rooskibar03; 10-08-2014 at 14:44.
    Progressive ideology, ideas so good they must be mandatory.
    Your freedom to be you includes my freedom to be free from you.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •