I rented both of these and shoot both well. I know the Ruger is less expensive. (Cabelas has it for 319 right now). I like both a days trying to decide on my conceal carry. I carry in jacket pocket a lot or shorts pocket. I have a G17 and know it's a tank. Sweat won't bother it. I heard a rumor about the Ruger having issues with sweat (when carrying IWB)

Anyone have experience with either or have opinions?