Good call on Shane Co. I'm late in this thread but this is who I went with 7 years ago and couldn't have been happier since. Warranty included, which we had to use when one of my wife's smaller diamonds came loose. No hassle and quick turn around. Had my ring polished a few times too.

Funny story: My wife and I stopped into a jewelry store near Colorado Mills (forget the name - right across from Target) to look at stuff. We're looking at these "chocolate diamonds" and I say something like "I don't like those at all...." to my wife. The sales beeotch interjects and says smugly, "Those are very popular right now". Me: "Not with me". Snotty beeotch walks away.

Later, my wife is looking at something and she's bs-ing with the same beeotch. I just walk up and stand there when they're talking warranty and the sales bitch says something about how Shane's warranty is bullshit and they don't stand by their guarantee, etc. I say, "We just had my wife's wedding ring repaired under warranty and had no problems." Sales beeotch says, "But you had to pay for it, right?". Me, "No....let's go babe."

Congrats man!