Quote Originally Posted by NFATrustGuy View Post
It's funny that you brought this up as I'm having the exact same issue. They replaced one of my 2 water heaters and a water circulation pump just before I bought my house. A couple of months later, I had the second water heater replaced under warranty. I still have water dribbling out on the floor so I put some catch pans under the various heaters and vent pipes to see what, exactly, was still leaking...

Turns out it was the pressure relief valve on the #1 water heater. Did a little reading and am convinced that I need one of those expansion tanks to moderate the pressure spikes. It's on my list of things to do, too. Gotta sit and think about the logic of the system to figure out where it should be placed based on how the 2 water heaters are plumbed to the water system.

Fun times as a homeowner.
The best way to know if you need one is if you have any check valve or backflow preventer you need an expansion tank. With a lack of back flow preventer it will just push against the city pressure and not pop or valve.