Recommend a Grill for under $500

[muddywings]

My sears Kenmore from 2000 has had a good life but it's time to retire her to the trash can.
Need a simple backyard propane grill for under $500. Nothing fancy (aka don't care about side burners or rotisseries).
I have few targets from Amazon but could use some outside opinions.
and go...

[kwando]

I use to always buy cheap $100-200 grills, yes they lasted 5+ years. But when I moved I bought a new Weber Genesis grill and boy are they nice! Better heat, way easier to clean, drip trays are awesome, well worth it to step up to a weber. That is what my recommendation is.

[Great-Kazoo]

Buy once cry once, providing you're not planning on moving the next 3-5 years. Weber is good, but look at the higher end Char-Broiler. We picked up a scratch n dent (floor model) CB that's lasted 4.5 years.

[Erni]

Dont get another kenmore. My old one which lasted 15years with some minor fixes was great. Replaced with a new kenmore. Stainless, etc, looked really nice. Uneven heat, always blazes up due to the way they did the lighter setup. I will be buying a new grill when funds allow.

If you just need the 3 burner version then look at the weber and pay a bit more.

[Ramsker]

I traded up to a Weber (E310) this summer after running my old grill into the ground and really like it. Ace Hardware was running a deal with $50 gift card included with purchase. They may still be doing that. I don't think you generally find a ton of variance in pricing--at least there wasn't when I was looking.

[mjzman]

Try a Broil King. Lowe's carries them but may have to order. Canadian company. Equal to perhaps slightly better specs than equivalent Weber at a slightly lower price.
I bought one last spring to replace an eight year old Char Broil which would not go over 350 degrees. The Broil King heats to 700 degrees.

[Sawin]

How are you guys disposing of your old grills? Putting them out by the curb on trash day or with a “free” sign?

[Eric P]

They are steel. Put on curb and post a Craigs list ad. Scrappers will take care of it for you

[Ramsker]

How are you guys disposing of your old grills? Putting them out by the curb on trash day or with a “free” sign?

Yup. In Highlands Ranch, if you put almost anything of value out the night before trash pickup . . . someone will come by and pick it up. I don't know if they use the stuff or try to resell it, but my grill was on the driveway for about 3 hours before it was gone.

[gnihcraes]

Had two weber propane, love them. Get many years of service out of them, parts are usually available. (flavor bars, burners) Grant it, this is after 10+ years use.

Their small Q line is great for camping, uses small propane bottles or extended hose to normal sized tank if needed.