Awkward situation

[WETWRKS]

Ok...so during the Clintons they tried pulling a stunt where they told the feds to deny purchases. If you didn't appeal you would end up permanently denied. At that time I decided to by a .50DE. Went and bought from Paladin Arms which had moved from Boulder to Longmont. They did the background check and it came back with a 24 hour delay. Called the next day to find it had changed to a 3 day delay. Called back 3 days later and it had been changed to denied. There was zero reason for a denial on me. They said to come up and get my money back and they had a form to appeal the denial. That paperwork stated specifically if I didn't appeal I would be permanently denied. It also stated that either way I would receive in writing the reason behind the denial. I filled out the papers and sent them in. A month later I got a call from Paladin and they had received an all clear for me to come collect the gun. I went up and they took payment and I left with the gun. I have purchased numerous firearms since without a hiccup. It was a few years later that I heard about the Clintons trying to get people added to the denied list by this method.

I never received anything in any way that stated why I had been denied. The only response was their call to Paladin approving the sale.

Your buyer may be legitimately innocent in this and his embarrassment may be genuine and deserved. I know I was certainly embarrassed when it happened to me. I felt embarrassment even after having been cleared. The employees seemed to act oddly when I went back to get the gun. It was possibly just my perception or they may have felt odd that I had been denied to begin with. Don't know. I do know it was pretty uncomfortable. They asked what I might have done to be denied both when it came back as denied as well as after being approved as if even tho I was cleared I was still somehow guilty of something.

[ray1970]

I was denied once. Apparently if your driver?s license expires then you no longer have a valid form of identification so they deny you.

Renewed the stupid thing and everything went fine.

[FromMyColdDeadHand]

I used the electronic form at centennial the other day, and it makes you put in a email address? At first I left it blank for many reasons, but it wouldn?t let me proceed until I put one in. When did that start happening? You have to have an email address to buy a gun?

[MrPrena]

Doesn't mean anything, happens all the time, doesn't mean you are an ax murderer
Sometimes it's only an unpaid parking ticket...
We had somebody fail because of an unpaid off-leash dog ticket...
25 years ago...
The dog is fucking dead, FFS!
THE MAN will always get his money, one way or the other.

^^^^^ This
Around ~5 years ago, I had a guy who was buying an FN FNX the store. He was suppose to call me and go to the range. Apparently he was hauled to county immediately to pay for the parking. He picked up the firearm on the same day, but little late for me to go to the range together.

Place like Boulder, people do get a parking ticket even if you are 30 second late. I've seen parking enforcement officer issuing ticket (in the 90s) 2 minutes before meter expired too.

Should taken full payment up front.

They fail, not your problem. The FFL has a free gun in his inventory.

What's with you always encouraging members to steal other people's money?

how is that stealing someone's money?

The gun is his after payment, but can't take it home from the FFL until his permission slip is approved. If he fails on appeal and abondons it at the FFL, how is the seller stealing? The seller is under no obligation to make sure the buyer passes his background check. That is a consequence of silly unnecessary universal background checks.

The buyer can ask the FFL to sell the gun for a fee or store it for a fee. The sellers obligation ends with cash in hand and transferring it to the ffl for the background check.

This isn't like dealing with Craigslist and a rare occurrence, sorry you have such a selfish outlook. At worst besides the bgc fee etc, id maybe ask for a $20 for time and fuel.

Because if someone pays you for something, and they don't get that thing, you've stolen their money.

All of the comments are correct, but it really depends on who the FFL is.
Few stores said that it is upto the buyer and the store to arrange a transfer (re-do background, or sell it to different places). Basically, those few stores said it is between Buyer and FFL issue. Seller gets paid.
Majority of stores was saying that I need to get the firearm back after doing background check on my own firearm.

[FoxtArt]

FTR, people who advocate taking money up front and letting them deal with it fail to realize that is a HUGE asshole move to the dealer.

You go to the dealer to transfer your gun from party A to party B. If the dealer is following all the advice on private party transfers, they are not filling out firearm info and if denied, your weapon has not been entered into their books at all.

So for a presumptuous customer to say "Whelp dealer, its your problem now, you are obligated to sell it on your shelf and fight with this guy who wants his money back"

....

I know a few dealers who would tell such a customer how far a fist can be shoved up a butt. Not attacking anyone here, just remember that when you are doing a private party transfer, everyone - please don't be a dick to the dealer.

[Acetylcholine]

Well said FoxtArt. It sucks as a dealer having to resell someone else’s gun if they can’t pass CBI. The amount of emails, phone calls, lowball Armslist offers for a gun that you’re not making profit on is hardly worth your time. I’m still trying to sell a couple guns where the buyers couldn’t pass CBI. It’s part of the game.

[Doc45]

FoxtArt +++

[funkymonkey1111]

FTR, people who advocate taking money up front and letting them deal with it fail to realize that is a HUGE asshole move to the dealer.

Is the dealer not adequately protected with its transfer fee? Nobody requires a dealer to perform this transaction.

[Circuits]

I've had a personal sale to a neighbor fail. He said he was going to appeal, but never got back to me. Heard it was related to some unresolved DUI stuff, but don't know for sure.

Figger its nunma.

[FoxtArt]

Is the dealer not adequately protected with its transfer fee? Nobody requires a dealer to perform this transaction.

Is a quick lube properly compensated to replace your engine if you only paid for an oil change which they properly performed, and it isnt in any way their fault that your engine blew?

Lol...