Stewart, I don't understand the chemistry behind the various lubes available to do a good write up on this YET. I'm hoping in a couple of years to have been edjamukated enough in chemistry to do something like this.
What I do understand is how various lubes have acted/reacted in the various guns I've shot in various conditions. CLP just hasn't cut it for me. CLP started life as Break Free and being used to soak steel parts that had stuck together from corrosion. It penetrates steel very well. This equals being soaked up by steel like a sponge soaking up water, especially in warmer temps or in guns heated through lots of shooting. I had huge issues with this in the desert. If in doubt, I just use motor oil. The synthetics seem to not thicken when heated up from shooting and resist thickening in cold weather.