Do you have to be a member?
Colorado AR-15 Shooters Club Discussion Forums
Welcome to the Colorado AR-15 Shooters Club Discussion Forums.
Welcome to the Colorado AR-15 Shooters Club Discussion Forums.
Do you have to be a member?
Nope, it's a public range, I think it's $8 or so.Originally Posted by MB888
Nagorheli already answered but, no, it's a public range.
I'll be on the 200 yard (usually less busy except for the good ol' benchrest boys) and I'll bring the clay thrower if anyone is interested and some boom cans. I should have a legality answer (in writing) sometime Friday from Dep. Bowen. He's a CSPD rangemaster and also on the bomb squad, etc. He's also talking to inspector Maneri from teh ATF. Should clear everything up concerning Tannerite for all the naysayers who were having issues with it.
why bother with CSPD? dragonman's is way outside city limits.
mel blasts cars with 50 cals out there.
tannerite shouldn't be a problem.
Rgr I know, just with the way the last tannerite thread went and some people saying they weren't sure they wanted to partake, I figured I'd just get some documentation from city and Feds to put the nay sayers at ease.
I have 30 lbs I'll be having fun with regardless if others partake. Just want people to be at ease and have fun, not worrying about gettin' thrown in jail, etc.
People do need to bring their own ammo though. I'm not rich, lol. I'll try to have 200 or so clays so if people want more, they'll have to bring 'em.
well according to the way the regs read Tannerite would be illegal
and so far, .50 calibers aren't.
public/private range aside, illegal possession of an explosive isn't a charge I want on my record.
I understand Byte, hence me jumping through some hoops here to get you and others some solid answers in writing.
If it does help ease your conscience, Mel does have an explosives liscence as well and he rigs those cars to blow with showman pyrotechniques/explosions, etc. The range is also private property even though he runs the business (which is also liscenced) off of it.
But in the grand scheme of things, I understand that "it doesn't matter if the product is still not kosher!" If you come you don't have to shoot 'em or even touch 'em. You can be on a different lane and disavow any knowledge of having safe fun! (messing with you brother)
Answers about legality, etc.
Bottom line: Legal as long as it is not premixed or transported while mixed. No liscence needed for the manufactered amounts sold via the Tannerite website. They do express concerns and hesitancy about people using it that have no explosives knowledge/liscense, etc.
I have a written letter heading my way expressing the above.
Below are the emails. I'll begin with the initial email and then just post the replies as we hash things out. Some things and emails were edited out as they had no relevance to the original conversation. If you would like to check the originals for validity, I'll keep 'em for a while. Ok, on to the emails:
Original email:
Hello Randy, et al.,
First and foremost: Happy New Year! I hope and pray that all is well with you and yours! Now, on to business. I am trying to figure out the legality of using Tannerite Reactive Targets for personal use on established ranges. Several range masters have indicated that they would not have any problems letting me use the product as long as I am safe, it's legal, and all that jazz. While researching the product I've have come upon several inconsistencies and just want to make sure everything is legal before I proceed.
Here are the claims of Tannerite issued on their webpage: http://www.tannerite.com/frequent-qu...oding-targets/
- Tannerite is a binary explosive used for firearms practice.
- It is completely stable when subjected to less severe forces such as hammer blows or being dropped.
- It is exceptionally safer than black powder.
- It cannot be set off using flame or electricity.
- Designed for high powered rifle use only, it cannot be set off with rim fire or small caliber (slow moving) pistol cartridges.
- It is supplied as two powders (ammonium nitrate blend with zinc I think as the catalyst) which are combined to produce the explosive.
- It is patented and trade marked.
- Explosion consists of water vapor in a white "dust" cloud and loud boom.
- Since the two components are not explosive until mixed, they can be legally purchased without a license.
They claim that they would love to talk to any authorities and discuss it's legality, so: Tannerite's phone number if more information is needed: 541.744.1406
Here is where my questions lay:
- In Colorado law, even though written for liquid explosives, it does state that "binary" explosives are illegal.
Source: Explosive Regs from the CO Division of Oil and Public Safety.
- Explosive Materials: These include explosives, blasting agents, and detonators... Binary explosives, sold in two or more components, are considered an explosive material requiring a Division of Oil and Public safety explosives permit.
Question is: If this is the case, how do I obtain a Division of Oil and Public safety explosives permit? Seems kind of overkill for a simple reactive target.
- In Federal law there are restrictions on the civilian detonation of materials in excess of 4 oz. So that would apparently mean the detonation of .5 and 1lb "cans" of Tannerite could be construed as violations of current BATFE regulations.... insane....
Bottom line: Would it be okay to use this product or do I need to find out how to obtain permits and their costs, etc? Would it be possible to use on private land then since the owning of such product is not in question, it seems to be the actual detonation.
Thank you for taking the time to read and respond to this. We appreciate everything y'all do for us in El Paso county. Take care and God Bless.
Sincerely,
Tim Baird
Responses:
Gentlemen, beyond the local considerations, I have reached out to Pete Marini with ATF. The individual rifle/pistol targets are not regulated. In excess of certain amounts of Tannerite binary explosive materials may require some kind of permit. He will get specifics and call me tomorrow.
J.D.
Lt. J.D. Ross, Training Director
El Paso County Sheriff's Office
__________________________________________________ ____________
Tim,
I talked with Corey and he reached to get answers to your questions. His respsonse is below. As Range Master for the EPSO / Public Safety Training Facility, I would be hesitant to allow this on our range based on the concerns expressed by The Regional Biomb Commander Chris Arseneau. Officer Compton, CSPD Range Master / Public Safety Traing Facility, concurs with this reservation. But, it seems it is not illegal to use.
Please feel free to contact me if you have any further questions.
Randy
Deputy R.W. Bowen - Range Master
El Paso County Sheriff's Office
Public Safety Training Facility
5695 S. Academy Blvd.
(719) 502-2272 - Office
________________________________
Hey Randy,
In regards to your question about the Tannerite for the target shooting I talked to Chris Arseneau (CSPD/EPSO Regional Bomb Squad Commander) about some of the things that you were asking about. Essentially he said that it is not illegal to transport or ship in Colorado since it is sent in two separate containers. Now once the binary is mixed, it does become (and is considered) a high explosive so it would need to be used at that time. What he meant by this is that unless they have a permit to transport and store explosives, they can’t mix it and store it anywhere because it when then fall under state regulation.
Chris also mentioned that although it is considered by many to be a stable explosive, it can be shock sensitive and set off that way. I asked him straight out if he thought it was worth the risk and trouble to use it in target shooting as it is advertised on the website. He stated that although many people have made homemade versions of it and have tried to use it in shooting, he didn’t feel it was worth the potential risk involved in using and handling a high explosive with no training to do so.
If you have any questions for Chris, you can always call him at 444-7712.
Let me know if there’s anything else I can do…
Corey
__________________________________________________ ____________
J.D. has no further email. However, he did call me after speaking to Inspector Marini. Everything is legal as long as it's not premixed/stored/transported. It must be used on spot, etc. They advised against mixing anything larger than 1lb though technically, it wouldn't be illegal.
So again, bottom line: Tannerite it GTG. Just need to make sure DM is ok with it and the last 20 times I've been out there, Mel's never had a problem as long as it didn't disturb anyone, wasn't busy, etc and etc. I ask every time and get a GTG every time... doesn't hurt that his daughter and my wife hang out I guess... HAHA.
I sent everyone a thank you email and also told 'em I'd have no problem with taking take them to the range so they can experience it themselves or even giving their rangemaster or bomb techs a few samples.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote