Yeah I was in the same boat two years ago. I went with the Liberty Centurian 20 close to that price range and I am now completely out of room. I am now saving for a FatBoy Junior. I will also agree buy as big as you can or you will be doing what I'm doing and that is just buying another safe that is larger sooner than expected. I have small kids in the house so it is an absolute priority to me to have everything locked up. It seems to me however many guns the safe is rated for, divide that by two especially with rifles. I can maybe fit 6 rifles in mine but plenty of pistols on the shelves.