Giving? So now someone who works for a job is a taker? Rich people don't create jobs because they benevolent or because they are charitable. Hell NO, they do it because there is DEMAND for something and if there is a way for them to make more money by hiring someone, they will. YOU AND I are the people who drive demand to create jobs. Since the wealthy have been hording all the increases in wealth (productivity gains), the demand dropped off. They powers that be hid that economic collapse by making credit cheap. So we never saw the drop in wages till the crash of credit. You guys are off in la la land if you think the rich are job creators. It stands your whole free market theory on its head.