Basil Hayden's is the shiznit.

I've also been digging the Ri1 lately. Yeah, I know, it's a Jim Beam product but just the same it's pretty good rye.

And every cigar will be cheaper online than at a store. Nothing wrong with a storefront as a place to put your feet up and smoke your purchase with a book for a few hours, but one way is definitely cheaper than the other.