I have bought at Erie Gold and Coin a couple of times. There prices were hit and miss, sometimes they were very close to spot, other times too far above for me. The main issue I had was that I allocated X number of dollars to spend on silver, but they never had enough on hand for me to buy all that I was looking for.

They are worth giving a call to see what they have on hand and their price. From my experience, they are nice guys, and treat you fair.