Form 1 question

[Lurch]

Not to hijack the thread, but do you build the upper BEFORE you apply or after you get the approval? What if something (availability, etc) changes between your intent on the form and the actual implementation a year later when you get approval?

By the law you can't have the upper without the stamp. You can build the upper and give it to someone else that doesn't have a lower or a rifle that it will fit on unless that person has a Form 1 SBR stamp. You can always build it as a pistol and then make it an SBR once the stamp arrives. Also if you change things that don't jive with what the original Form 1 says you will be in violation. You can always build different uppers for the SBR as long as you keep the original upper.

[brutal]

By the law you can't have the upper without the stamp. You can build the upper and give it to someone else that doesn't have a lower or a rifle that it will fit on unless that person has a Form 1 SBR stamp. You can always build it as a pistol and then make it an SBR once the stamp arrives. Also if you change things that don't jive with what the original Form 1 says you will be in violation. You can always build different uppers for the SBR as long as you keep the original upper.

Doesn't this contradict another thread that says SBR is SBR and once on a form 1 any length is permissible?

[Random]

By the law you can't have the upper without the stamp. You can build the upper and give it to someone else that doesn't have a lower or a rifle that it will fit on unless that person has a Form 1 SBR stamp. You can always build it as a pistol and then make it an SBR once the stamp arrives. Also if you change things that don't jive with what the original Form 1 says you will be in violation. You can always build different uppers for the SBR as long as you keep the original upper.

This makes me think I should buy all the parts before I submit the form 1, since know one knows what Mustapha Mond will do by the time it gets approved . If I leave them all in boxes and don't even look at one with a tool in hand is that still constructive intent? I DO like the idea of "pistol" upper, but if I don't have a "pistol" lower built does that still work?

This also opens the can of "what is a pistol" worms that I also haven't got my head wrapped around...AFAIK the lower was listed as "other" when purchased and a stock was never installed...

I've already pinged NFAGuy on most of this, we'll see what the resident guru thinks.

[Lurch]

This makes me think I should buy all the parts before I submit the form 1, since know one knows what Mustapha Mond will do by the time it gets approved . If I leave them all in boxes and don't even look at one with a tool in hand is that still constructive intent? I DO like the idea of "pistol" upper, but if I don't have a "pistol" lower built does that still work?

This also opens the can of "what is a pistol" worms that I also haven't got my head wrapped around...AFAIK the lower was listed as "other" when purchased and a stock was never installed...

I've already pinged NFAGuy on most of this, we'll see what the resident guru thinks.

If you have all the parts you can still build it so you would be in violation. A pistol doesn't have a stock on it and you must use a pistol buffer tube, you can build it as a pistol since it was sold as an other then just convert it to an SBR once you have your stamp.

[Random]

If you have all the parts you can still build it so you would be in violation. A pistol doesn't have a stock on it and you must use a pistol buffer tube, you can build it as a pistol since it was sold as an other then just convert it to an SBR once you have your stamp.

Okay, this is making sense. Start with a pistol buffer tube, when the form 1 comes back I put on a rifle stock and it's an SBR. At that point I can never put the pistol buffer back on and call it a pistol, or can I since "SBR" seems more restrictive than "pistol" and I have the stamp?

[Lurch]

Okay, this is making sense. Start with a pistol buffer tube, when the form 1 comes back I put on a rifle stock and it's an SBR. At that point I can never put the pistol buffer back on and call it a pistol, or can I since "SBR" seems more restrictive than "pistol" and I have the stamp?

This I'm not certain on. But you can always get another lower and make it a pistol. But you will be too busy building uppers for your SBR and looking at suppressors.

[Random]

...you will be too busy building uppers for your SBR and looking at suppressors.

*sigh* I believe you are correct. Why have one contact point when you can have three? Quietly?

Thanks for the help, and apologies to the OP if my hijack took this too far off his topic!