Why do people have to make problems?

[SMOGSONE]

It's time to get defensive if and when the LEO might push the issue beyond a reasonable measure and asking for ID isn't it.

Asking for and ID for no other reason then the fact the person is open carrying in a place where it is legal, in and of it self is infringing on that persons rights. I would have to say ANY time a persons rights are infringed on in any way (even if slightly) is a good time to get defensive.

I feel stopping me to see my ID because i am carrying a gun to "be sure im not a felon" is about as offensive and out of line as it would be to stop me for ID as I carry my child to be sure im not sex offender.

[Ronin13]

Asking for and ID for no other reason then the fact the person is open carrying in a place where it is legal, in and of it self is infringing on that persons rights. I would have to say ANY time a persons rights are infringed on in any way (even if slightly) is a good time to get defensive.

I feel stopping me to see my ID because i am carrying a gun to "be sure im not a felon" is about as offensive and out of line as it would be to stop me for ID as I carry my child to be sure im not sex offender.

Welcome, and please post in the new member sign in... as for your logic, spot on! I would get on the defensive a bit too if a LEO asked for my ID when he doesn't need to (pretty much anything that isn't a traffic stop).