Yes.
I came from Wink to HE in early Sep as they've been circling the drain thanks to Will.I.Am and problematic to say the least for quite some time.
I did quite a bit of research before moving and while the somewhat lack of maturity of the HE is apparent, the lack of dependency on all things cloud for local control was most attractive. ST has seen a fair amount of abandonment among the heavy HA user community lately, all flocking to HE.
Since we're using HA mostly for automation and voice control via Alexa, I'm not to troubled by the infancy of the dashboard/tile setup and the app has presence detection so it's useful to some degree. If the internet or API's are down, I can still use a local HE dashboard/app or wall switches. I've dumped all the "smart bulbs" that repeat (GE and Cree) because they're shitty Zigbee repeaters and put in AC powered Zigbee/Zwave wall plugs and a few non repeating Zigbee bulbs.
If I wasn't concerned about cloud dependency and wasn't heavily invested in Z-Wave as well as Zigbee and Lutron (had to buy a Lutron PRO2 hub to work with HE), I would probably just run everything Zigbee on Echo's hub. I understand Ring also has some Zigbee hub capabilities now, but it's really immature and limited.
As to installing apps in HE, it comes minimally loaded by design and most of the apps are actually provided by HE and just need to be installed if you use them (or not). The add-on community apps are very nice if needed. Most oare stable, some can be problematic. HE has a VERY powerful rules engine so you can do a ton with automation and it's all LOCAL and private (unless you link into cloud API's for other stuff).
I've got HE telling Alexa to speak things (via Echo Speaks), Alexa controlling HE via the provided Alexa App and most of my other automation is handled by "Simple Lighting" and "Motion Lighting." Setting modes based on time of day. luminance, presence etc is simple and effective.
All in all, I'm very pleased with HE and the powerful controls. The add on community apps are useful, and the support community is helpful. There's been lots of negative traffic lately because frankly, there's a bunch of really dumb people that were running Wink that just don't have the skills to setup HE.
My Feedback
Credit TFOGGER : Liberals only want things to be "fair and just" if it benefits them.
Credit Zundfolge: The left only supports two "rights"; Buggery and Infanticide.
Credit roberth: List of things Government does best; 1. Steal your money 2. Steal your time 3. Waste the money they stole from you. 4. Waste your time making you ask permission for things you have a natural right to own. "Anyone that thinks the communists won't turn off your power for being on COAR15 is a fucking moron."
Not sure if that was Greek or Latin. Maybe just nerd talk?![]()
Hehehe Ray... my translator said:
Words & more words & maybe a feeling...
My airstream has been stolen by dopers
I'm not fat, I'm tactically padded.
Tactical Commander - Fast Action Response Team (F.A.R.T.)
For my feedback Click Here.
Click: For anyone with a dog or pets, please read
My Feedback
Credit TFOGGER : Liberals only want things to be "fair and just" if it benefits them.
Credit Zundfolge: The left only supports two "rights"; Buggery and Infanticide.
Credit roberth: List of things Government does best; 1. Steal your money 2. Steal your time 3. Waste the money they stole from you. 4. Waste your time making you ask permission for things you have a natural right to own. "Anyone that thinks the communists won't turn off your power for being on COAR15 is a fucking moron."
The Great Kazoo's Feedback
"when you're happy you enjoy the melody but, when you're broken you understand the lyrics".